This post originally appeared on the Green Building Advisor Website. www.greenbuildingadvisor.com.
I’ve been a licensed journeyman electrician since 2000 (I haven’t worked as an electrician since 2005, but still keep my licensing requirements up to date). Back in those days no one was asking us to seal the penetrations for electrical equipment we were making to the outside or into unconditioned spaces. Even today, with building codes requiring all air passageways between conditioned and unconditioned spaces sealed, it’s rare that the electricians are performing those duties. It’s usually left to the insulating contractor, a member of the carpentry crew, or in the case of holes drilled to the exterior of the building, the siding contractor. I can speak with experience that, with a little training, the residential mechanical/electrical/plumbing (MEP) trades are more than capable of sealing their own holes and penetrations. I’m finding the MEP contractors I’m working with are taking pride in performing those duties.
What I see in older homes.
Performing energy audits and blower door tests in older homes as taught me where to look for air leaks. Often, thermal imaging will find the unsealed electrical and plumbing holes that have been drilled into unconditioned attic and crawlspaces. This thermal image (taken during the summer when the attic space was hotter than the living space) shows both an unsealed wire penetration (right) and unsealed plumbing vent (left) that connect the home with unconditioned attic. Hot air during the blower door test was being drawn down these holes and into this wall cavity. In the case of the electrical penetration, the air was entering the home through the light switch on an interior wall. The plumbing penetration was an air pathway from the basement to the attic. The blower door created an artificial pressure to allow us to find these leaks. What is happening naturally in my very cold climate is the conditioned air, which containing at least some moisture, is being “pushed” out these holes during the heating season due to the stack effect. If the moisture in this exfiltrating air reaches a condensing surface inside the unconditioned attic, water or frost will accumulate on that cold surface. At a minimum, there is wasted energy, but there could also be a building durability concern.
Sealing the holes.
There are several methods we can use to seal holes and openings used for electrical wires, electrical boxes and other electrical equipment. Let’s start with the “other equipment”. Typically, the biggest hole an electrician will make in a home’s envelope will be for the main electrical service conductors, the large diameter wires that go between the meter base or equipment disconnect and service panel.
Most modern homes will be equipped with a minimum of a 200-amp panel, the wires feeding that panel will usually come through a 2-inch conduit with the hole through the building envelope accommodating that conduit at 2 ½ inches. There are two concerns, one is the hole drilled for the conduit. We will need to make the space around the conduit is both water and airtight. Sealing the exterior space around the conduit is simple, using a quality sealant to connect the conduit to the water and/or air control layer is one way, my preferred method though is to use some sort of gasket, this allows movement of the conduit during both installation and in the possibility of expansion and contraction of the conduit during the temperature fluctuations it may see over its service life. A gasket such as this Pro-Flash can create both a water and air-tight connection.
An option for eliminating the needed hole in the air barrier for the electrical conduit is to route the conduit so that it enters the home from underground, either under a slab or through a foundation wall, This requires planning during the construction of the foundation, but it can lessen the bulk water risk and reduce or eliminate the air sealing inside the conduit, which is the second concern, the space inside the conduit. The wires fill the majority of the space, but there is still a potential air pathway into the home.
The electrical code is specific on what is allowed for air sealing the wires inside the conduit.
NEC-2020 300.5(G)
“Conduits or raceways through which moisture may contact live parts shall be sealed or plugged at either or both ends. Spare or unused raceways shall also be sealed. Sealants shall be identified for use with the cable insulation, conductor insulation, bare conductor, shield, or other components.”
The code states, the sealant needs to be identified for use… What electrical inspectors do not want to see is a product that can trap the heat that the wires may produce while in service, so using canned spray foam to seal the wires in the conduit is a no-no. The product we used when I was working full-time as an electrician is Duct Seal. Duct Seal is a non-hardening putty used to seal the irregular gaps of electrical wires that are inside a conduit. It can be easily removed if the wires inside the conduit need to be changed. Not the easiest product to work with, trying to pack around and between multiple wires can be difficult, but the product is approved for this application.
The next set of holes that require sealing are the ones that contain the non-metallic sheathed (Romex) style or an equivalent type of cable. Outside lighting, outlets, and other exterior electrical equipment that requires power will have at least one wire supplying those devices and equipment. Often there are multiple wires (or other products such as an AC or heat pump line set) in one hole such as in the next photo. There is a wire bunched in with this bundle of air conditioner line sets (Left photo). Very difficult to both make watertight and create an effective air barrier. The photo to the right is of Jake Bruton’s personal house and the strategy he used to simplify this problem, one hole, one wire or pipe.
Jake used a liquid flash product for the seal, my preference is again, to use a gasket. These wires and pipes will be pushed and pulled during the installation of the equipment, possibly breaking both the water and air seal the liquid flash is providing. A gasket will allow for greater movement while maintain the seal. Siga recently released a new Fentrim gasket designed for this purpose. The gasket is available in various sizes, including for specific non-metallic sheathed cable sizes such as 14-2 or 12-2. They can be used on the exterior for water and air management, or on the interior, simply for air control. The photo shows the gasket designed for 14-2.
My MEP contractors were not excited about using this “one hole” method the first time, but after explaining why and gaining some experience on how its done, they now use the method without me even needing to remind them, as a mater of fact, one of the contractors has implemented this practice on all his projects.
Electrical boxes are another potential hole in either or both the water and air control layers. I wrote an article recently on this topic. Airtight Electrical Boxes – GreenBuildingAdvisor
Sealing holes inside wall cavities is the next subject. Again, I prefer to follow the one hole, one wire method to assure the best air seal possible. Can two wires in a hole be air sealed? I’m sure they can, but three or more will create a leak point, not a lot of air, but if you are trying to hit a blower door metric, cutting down on several small leaks can be helpful. Sealing the penetration can be accomplished using canned expanding foam or a quality sealant. One of the tricks is to make sure all the wires are fastened and no longer need to be moved or adjusted. Tugging on a wire after air sealing is complete can break the seal.
An alternative to sealing wires that leave the conditioned space of the home is to keep as many as possible inside. Creating a service cavity when the main air control is located on the inside of the wall and roof assembly, or moving the main air control to the exterior of the home can satisfy this requirement. Using a plenum truss or by fastening a 2x flat on a wall or ceiling after installing a membrane for the air control are both techniques I’ve used in the past.
Electrical penetrations in the air control layer are not typically the biggest leak points, but they are a part of the overall picture in air tightness for a home. Often paying attention to these smaller details can make all the difference between a good and a great blower door score.